The Commander (2023) Movie Review: A Story of Heroism and Moral Integrity Amidst War

The Commander (2023), directed by Edoardo De Angelis, is a compelling World War II drama that tells the true story of Italian submarine commander Salvatore Todaro. With a focus on heroism, humanity, and moral dilemmas in the face of war, the film explores a pivotal moment during the Battle of the Atlantic when Commander Todaro made a courageous decision that would defy the orders of his superiors and change the lives of 26 Belgian survivors.

Set against the backdrop of one of the darkest periods in history, The Commander is a film that invites audiences to reflect on the true cost of doing what is right, even when it comes at a personal and professional cost. Featuring a powerful performance by Pierfrancesco Favino as Commander Todaro, the film highlights themes of compassion, integrity, and selflessness in a time when survival and duty often clashed.

Plot Overview: The Dilemma of Duty vs. Humanity

In the midst of World War II, the Italian submarine Cappellini successfully sinks an enemy merchant vessel in the Atlantic Ocean. As the survivors of the sunken ship—26 Belgians—are left stranded in the open sea, Commander Salvatore Todaro faces a moral dilemma. Although the ship was carrying cargo meant for the British enemy, Todaro makes a decision that would ultimately define his legacy.

Against the wishes of his superiors and military protocol, Todaro orders the rescue of the survivors, bringing them aboard his submarine. This courageous act goes against the very fabric of wartime strategy, which prioritizes military objectives over the well-being of individuals. Yet, for Todaro, the humanity of the situation outweighs the orders of war. The film captures the complexity of his decision, showing how this single act of compassion could potentially cost him his career, his reputation, and even his life.

The storyline of The Commander is more than just a war film—it is a poignant exploration of the human spirit in a time of unimaginable conflict. Todaro’s actions force the audience to confront difficult questions about loyalty, duty, and the power of individual choices.

Themes: Morality in Wartime and the Cost of Heroism

One of the central themes of The Commander is the moral ambiguity that soldiers face during wartime. As Todaro grapples with his decision to save the survivors, the film explores the tension between following orders and acting according to one’s ethical beliefs. In times of war, individuals are often forced to make decisions that could have dire consequences, and The Commander underscores the cost of choosing to act with humanity.

The movie also delves into the theme of heroism. Todaro’s decision is not motivated by fame or glory but by a deep sense of moral duty. In a world where most of the characters are driven by survival instincts and the harsh realities of war, Todaro’s actions stand in stark contrast. He chooses to risk everything for the sake of saving others, a choice that ultimately makes him a hero—not because of his rank or his actions during battle, but because of his compassion in the face of overwhelming adversity.

In addition to these themes, the film addresses the idea of personal sacrifice. By choosing to rescue the survivors, Todaro risks everything—his career, his reputation, and his relationship with his crew. The film portrays the emotional weight of this decision, showing the internal and external struggles that come with choosing to act in accordance with one’s moral compass rather than conforming to orders or following the status quo.

Critical Reception: A Powerful Performance and Cinematic Depth

Upon its release, The Commander was met with positive reviews for its emotional depth, engaging storytelling, and nuanced performances. Critics praised the film for its ability to focus on the human aspects of war, avoiding the usual political commentary that often overshadows stories of heroism.

Pierfrancesco Favino’s portrayal of Commander Salvatore Todaro has been widely regarded as the film’s standout performance. Favino masterfully brings to life the internal conflict of a man caught between his duty to his country and his moral beliefs. His portrayal of Todaro is both powerful and empathetic, capturing the essence of a man who, in the face of war, chooses to preserve his humanity.

The Guardian notes, “The Commander avoids complex political commentary, focusing instead on a moment of selfless heroism.” This choice to keep the film’s narrative grounded in personal morality rather than political agendas has resonated with audiences and critics alike, making it an emotionally rewarding experience.

Cinematography and Direction: A Visually Striking Historical Drama

The Commander is visually stunning, thanks to its meticulous direction and cinematography. Edoardo De Angelis uses the camera to not only capture the grand scale of the war but also to hone in on the intimate, emotional moments that define the story. The use of lighting, particularly in scenes aboard the submarine, adds a layer of tension and claustrophobia that reflects the internal struggle of the characters.

The film also pays great attention to historical accuracy, ensuring that the setting and period details are true to the World War II era. The authenticity of the environments—from the cold, vast ocean to the cramped, tension-filled submarine—enhances the immersive experience, transporting the audience into the heart of the conflict.

Where to Watch: Availability

The Commander is currently available in select cinemas across the UK and through various digital platforms. As the film continues to garner critical acclaim, it may become available in other regions. If you’re interested in experiencing this gripping historical drama, be sure to check local listings or streaming services for availability in your area.

Conclusion: A Poignant Reflection on Morality and War

In conclusion, The Commander is a film that masterfully combines historical drama with deep philosophical themes. It examines the complexities of war, the nature of heroism, and the moral choices that define us in times of great conflict. Through Commander Todaro’s story, the film emphasizes that the true courage in war is not found in victory but in the decision to protect and preserve human life, even at great personal risk.

For those who appreciate war films that explore the emotional and ethical implications of warfare, The Commander is a must-watch. It offers a powerful message about integrity, compassion, and the impact of individual actions in shaping history. With strong performances, a thought-provoking narrative, and stunning cinematography, The Commander is a film that will leave a lasting impression.

⭐ Final Rating: 8.5/10